Best Baby’s Teething Toys for Soothing Little Gums in 2025
We may earn a commission for purchases made using our links. Please see our disclosure to learn more.
If you’ve ever felt that little tug of guilt watching your baby fuss and chew on anything they can grab, you’re not alone. Teething can feel like a marathon—for both baby and parent. The swollen gums, endless drool, and restless nights are tough. That’s where the right baby’s teething toys come in, turning chaos into comfort.
In this guide, we’ll explore the best options available, what to look for in safe and soothing teething toys, and even how to avoid common mistakes many parents make. By the end, you’ll feel confident knowing which teething toy deserves a place in your diaper bag.
Why Choosing the Right Baby’s Teething Toys Matters
Babies put everything in their mouths. But teething toys aren’t just about distraction—they’re about relief, safety, and development. The wrong toy can be uncomfortable or even unsafe, while the right one can calm a fussy baby in seconds.
Signs That Your Baby Is Ready for Teething Toys
- Constant drooling
- Chewing on hands, clothes, or toys
- Fussiness, especially at night
- Swollen or red gums
What to Look for in Baby’s Teething Toys
- Material: Food-grade silicone or natural wood are parent favorites.
- Texture: Multiple surfaces to massage gums.
- Ease of Cleaning: Dishwasher safe is a lifesaver.
- Grip: Little hands need lightweight, easy-to-hold designs.
Types of Baby’s Teething Toys
Silicone Teething Toys
Soft yet durable, gentle on sore gums, and usually freezer-friendly.
Wooden Teething Rings
Natural, eco-friendly, and safe when untreated.
Water-Filled Teething Toys
Can be chilled for extra relief but must be carefully inspected for leaks.
Multi-Texture Teethers
Offer variety to keep babies engaged while soothing gums.
Why Silicone Is the Most Popular Choice
Parents often prefer silicone because it’s soft, chewable, and BPA-free. Plus, it’s easy to clean—making it the most practical day-to-day option.
Top 5 Baby’s Teething Toys on Amazon
Here are parent-approved picks to make life easier (and nights quieter).
1. Nuby Ice Gel Teether Keys
- Features: Multiple textured surfaces, chillable design.
- Pros: Affordable, easy for small hands.
- Cons: Doesn’t stay cold for long.
2. Sophie la Girafe Natural Rubber Teether
- Features: Made from 100% natural rubber, iconic design.
- Pros: Lightweight, visually engaging.
- Cons: Pricier than most options.
3. Mombella Mimi Mushroom Teether
- Features: Pacifier-style with soft silicone bristles.
- Pros: Helps transition from bottle to solids.
- Cons: Some babies may reject the shape.
4. Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether
- Features: Easy-grip handles, BPA-free silicone.
- Pros: Simple, durable, dishwasher safe.
- Cons: Limited textures.
5. Baby Elefun Teething Mitten
- Features: Wearable mitten with crinkle sound.
- Pros: Perfect for babies who drop everything.
- Cons: Needs frequent washing.
Quick Comparison Table
| Product | Material | Best For | Price Range |
| Nuby Ice Gel Keys | Silicone + Gel | Budget pick | $ |
| Sophie la Girafe | Natural Rubber | Premium option | $$$ |
| Mombella Mimi Mushroom | Silicone | Transitioning babies | $$ |
| Comotomo Teether | Silicone | Simplicity + durability | $$ |
| Elefun Teething Mitten | Fabric + Silicone | Hands-on relief | $$ |
How Teething Toys Help Development
- Motor skills: Grasping and chewing build coordination.
- Sensory exploration: Textures and shapes engage curiosity.
- Soothing rituals: Comfort toys create calming routines.
Best Practices for Cleaning Teething Toys
- Wash daily with warm soapy water.
- Use the dishwasher if safe.
- Avoid harsh chemicals—stick to baby-safe cleaners.
When to Replace Teething Toys
- Visible cracks or wear
- Sticky surfaces that don’t clean well
- After 3–6 months of heavy use
Common Mistakes Parents Make
- Choosing toys with unsafe paint or small detachable parts.
- Forgetting to clean teethers daily.
- Using frozen toys that are too hard and hurt gums.
Emotional Side of Teething: A Parent’s Story
When my niece was teething, she would cry endlessly at night until we found a soft silicone mushroom teether. It became her comfort buddy—she’d even hold it while falling asleep. That moment taught me teething toys aren’t just tools; they’re lifelines for both babies and parents.
🧪 Research-Backed Insights
Pediatric experts emphasize that teething toys provide sensory stimulation while easing gum pain. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics on teething relief, chilled (not frozen) teethers are safe and effective.
Another study published in the Journal of Pediatric Dentistry highlights that silicone and natural rubber toys are among the safest options for oral soothing. You can read more in this research review on teething safety.
FAQs About Baby’s Teething Toys
How many teething toys are recommended for infants?
Two to three different styles usually cover different needs—soft silicone, textured, and one freezer-friendly.
Are wooden teething toys safe?
Yes, as long as they’re untreated, splinter-free, and from reputable brands.
Is it safe to freeze teething toys?
Chill them, don’t freeze. Frozen toys can bruise sensitive gums.
When should I introduce teething toys?
Most babies start around 4–6 months, but it depends on their development.
When and how often should teething toys be washed?
Every day, and more often if dropped on the floor or outdoors.
Helpful Resource
If you’re creating a cozy nursery space, you might also love exploring these soft sheepskin throws to add warmth and comfort for your baby’s room.
Conclusion
The right baby’s teething toys can make the difference between restless nights and peaceful ones. Whether you go with a classic like Sophie la Girafe or a practical teething mitten, the key is choosing safe, soothing, and easy-to-clean options. Remember, you’re not just buying a toy—you’re investing in your baby’s comfort (and your sanity).
